In 2025, we named Heart Eyes as one of our best movies of the year. The horror flick starred Olivia Holt and Mason Gooding as two people working together on a campaign who end up in the crosshairs of a killer who murders on Valentine’s Day. It flew under the radar of many but it is a great blend of romantic thriller, slasher gore, and comedic gold. And, that Heart Eyes killer mask is kinda cool, too. The film ended with somewhat of a cliffhanger, so we are delighted that Paramount Pictures will bring a Heart Eyes 2 sequel to theaters on February 11, 2028. (Thanks to Variety for bringing this to our attention!)
At the end of Heart Eyes, Ally (Olivia Holt) gets a phone call from someone with the same menacing voice as the killer. This is obviously a shock to her considering some time has passed but it turns out to be her friend Monica (Gigi Zumbado) playing around. Monica tells Ally that she loves her but the line gets cut short, leaving her confused. We will surely figure out what that means in the next film.
We can assume that Gooding and Holt will reprise their roles as Ally and Jay and maybe Zumbado as Monica. But who will be the killer(s) this time around? We will have to wait a while and see what Valentine’s Day massacre happens in the Heart Eyes 2 sequel.