close menu
Episode 99: You Made It Weird
Paul Scheer
You Made It WeirdYou Made It Weird

You Made It Weird #99: Paul Scheer

Paul Scheer (The League! How Did This Get Made Podcast! Human Giant!) finally gets in the studio to make it wonderful and weird. Just a delightful and hilarious human man. God, we love us some Paul Scheer and hope you weirdos do too! GET INTO IT!

Follow @PaulScheer on Twitter and listen to How Did This Get Made!

Follow @peteholmez on Twitter and Like the show on Facebook. Buy YMIW shirts and Pete’s album “Impregnated with Wonder”!

Support the show by clicking on the banner below and shopping at!








  1. Chika says:

    For me Sunny is a hit or miss show, sometimes it is balrey makes me laugh and its “weak” episodes are really bad, imo. The League, no matter how boring the episode always generates 3 or 4 laugh out loud moments. I agree this season has been the weakest but I think that can be attributed more to the premise of the show wearing thin and the repetition of the humor. BUT to compare it to Dexter and Sunny to BBad is a horrible comparison, unless you are completely dismissive of football/fantasy football, then I could understand the comparison.

  2. David says:

    Knew I recognised Paul from somewhere – the Bates 3000 sketch from The Onion Movie.
    Man your exes sound like ridiculous loons. You’re better off with a donut when they’re that wrong in the head.
    Thanks for another great show.

  3. Jench says:

    Pete’s most unromantic thing ever is a lot like John Cusack’s conversation with his woman in High Fidelity…it isn’t all that romantic, but it’s not all that bad of a thing.

  4. Steph says:

    The black (purple) Smurfs were the GNAP. There is an improv theater group in Austin that goes by the same name. Nerd points! ….?

  5. Kass says:

    Bring Paul back often. He’s pretty perfect.

  6. Alec says:

    Paul’s comments on religion were interesting, but the one thing I’d argue is that sometimes there’s a valid reason for an atheist to make a fuss. For example, in Quebec, the rapid modernization and move away from the Church in the 60s has created a very secular society. They’re working at making it so that the government isn’t perceived as sticking up for one faith over another.

    Except that the crucifix in the National Assembly gets to stay for *historical* reasons. And rules banning overly religious garb with government employees would ban turbans and kippahs, but not crosses. Because, like Pete jokes (but some people seem to take seriously), Christianity is just *regular*. It’s everything else that has a religious connotation to it.

  7. Steve says:

    The image of Paul fingering Snow White and yelling “FUCK YOU, BITCH!” is incredible. Free podcast.

  8. Javier says:

    Pete. I think we can all agree this was a great episode. When are you having Max Silvestri on?

  9. MiklGipsin says:

    Getting these comments by email = :(

  10. Bill says:

    Not sure what religious folks you’re around, Jeff, but they ain’t that way at all here in the Bible Belt, where there’s the highest concentration of religion in the U.S. It’s WAY more than just an extracurricular activity. It dominates people’s lives, and it’s not simply a matter of no one pushing for it to evolve; it’s a matter of them fighting against the very idea of religion evolving. They consider the Bible perfect and infallible, literally the Word of God, so in their eyes any type of change is a bad thing. Crazy, I know, but that’s what they believe.

  11. Jeff MacDonald says:

    What Paul says about how religion has stopped evolving is an interesting point. I think major changes to christianity will not happen mostly because the church is not a part of the governing body any longer. The reformation occured during a time when religion was a part of the ruling class, so people rose up to change the ideas of religion because of the corruption that it was breeding. Now religion is an extracirricular for most people if they are religious. No one is clamoring for religion to evolve because it doesn’t effect their daily life.

    I would love to see some shake up in the world of christianity, judaism, or islam, but I just don’t think the pressures are there to push people for change. Unfortunately the rest of the world kept evolving, but religion stayed still for the most part.

  12. Noam says:

    Comedy, sex, god. Is there anything else worth talking about? I love you, Pete.

  13. I’m gonna sound totally obsessed, maybe that’s a good thing I don’t know. i just happened to click on an old EP on computer (#10 Alec Sulkin) and in that one you mentioned reading ‘God is not Great’ but you told Paul Scheer you hadn’t read it. Huh?
    Good night!

  14. What a great compliment, a brilliant Funnyman in his own right religulously listening to your show. Pete, you should invite Paul to do your show.

  15. M says:

    Stopped listening after you said sex is a hack for racism. No.

  16. Matt says:

    I’m not sure why, but I always thought Paul seemed like kind of an asshole. I was wrong and, indeed, he is a good dude.

  17. m0ntauk says:

    you have no idea how on point your portrayal of a generic office is. soul crushing.

  18. jsl says:

    This was hilarious, especially the first half hour. Can’t wait to re-listen

  19. laura says:

    Kale is a stunning superfood and I would like to hear more about it in life and in podcastz.
    I like to dice it up super fine (parsley style) and add it to the pan towards the end. (in a stir fry/tofu scramble etc)

    “…and our stock is down, and CFO…” Pete kneowz bizness!
    Mr Belding is a Poon hound? Lolz forevskies.
    Why would a bitches want to be sharin’ a suitcase? Absurd.

    <3 Paul Scheer! So open and engaging & ntsf:sd:suv is the best!

  20. Lisa says:

    Lovely episode, Pete!! Paul Scheer was a wonderful guest! Super crispy!!!

  21. Jacob says:

    Really enjoyed this episode.

  22. Charles H says:

    Right around the 10min mark Pete says “Frowned Upon” twice, and Paul does not say “In this Establishment”, missed opportunity.

  23. John says:

    Paul is one of my improv/comedic idols…Excited to listen!

  24. MiklGipsin says:

    YES, finally we can hear Paul Scheer give his opininon on Chelsea Peretti