close menu
Episode 41: You Made It Weird
Live from NYC w/ Jim…
You Made It WeirdYou Made It Weird

You Made It Weird #41: Live from NYC with Jim Gaffigan, Michael Ian Black and More!

THANK YOU to all the weirdos that came out to this live taping at the Gramercy Theater in NYC!! Michael Ian Black, Jim Gaffigan, Jessi Klein, and Matt McCarthy come and get weird live-style, plus SPECIAL DROP IN(s). Yes!! Such a fun one. Please enjoy, you weirdos!!

Buy Jim Gaffigan’s special Mr. Universe!

Listen to Michael Ian Black on Nerdist Industries own Mike and Tom Eat Snacks!

Follow @peteholmez on Twitter and Like the show on Facebook. And buy t-shirts at!

Support the show by clicking on the banner below and shopping at!







Special thanks to Carvin for supplying us with the equipment we need to record this podcast! Check out for more information on recording equipment, guitars, amps and more!


  1. Tillburg says:

    Honestly I liked the live show overall but Michael Ian Black really killed the mood every time he spoke. He was a super downer.

  2. Meh says:

    This episode was good up until Matt McCarthy came on. Not funny at all.

  3. the episode was really funny.share some funny videos with us in future.

  4. Ben says:

    The Marc Maron joke is hysterical.

  5. Omar Lopez says:

    So Michael Ian Black is like that in general, not just with Marc Maron. And oh man, why oh why was Chelsea Peretti there? Pete was absolutely killing at the beginning, and the rest of the show was decent. but Chelsea Peretti’s snarky bitchiness seriously got in the way. Hope this mean spirited, cruel trend in humor dies off soon.

  6. CXRengel says:

    When Mitt Romney get a running-mate, you and Matt McCarthy will have a bit where you can do your “We’re the Worst 2 People in the World” routine.

  7. Josh says:

    What??? Chelsea Paretti ON the show??? 349 “weirdos” died from alcohol poisoning listening to this podcast. Oh man, you made it deadly.

    Glad you packed the show! Sorry I couldn’t make it! Proud of my fellow Jews who made it there — just knew I’d be too sloshy with manischewitz for such crispiness. And it was! Crispy! Great show as usual, Pete!

  8. Christine says:

    I laughed so hard I was choking on my own air. So crispy!

  9. Jessica says:

    What a crispy episode I was laughing out loud the whole time!!!!!

  10. Julia Hays says:

    Oh, hey, that “I’m a Weirdo” sign was mine; thanks for the shout out, Pete! This episode was so much fun to see live. I took my mom to the city for the day, and by the end I think she became a “Weirdo” too!

  11. Kass says:

    Format pizzazz was lost, but I’ll bet if you narrowed it down to like two non Petes on stage instead of five you could probably get appropriately weird pretty quickly.

    Loved everyone on this and the audience was fun- hoping full episodes on the whole group are somewhere in the nearish future.

  12. Matt says:

    This was a good episode, but I’m not sure if a live audience is the best forum for the show. It seems like if put some of these guys in front of a crowd, they put on their comedian armor and don’t open up.