close menu


So you might have heard, even if you don’t read comics, that Marvel has replaced Aryan poster boy (slash All-American hero) Steve Rogers as Captain America with African American hero Sam Wilson, formerly known as the Falcon, for the launch of All-New Captain America, the first issue which hit this week. Aside from his long time status as Cap’s sidekick (he even co-headlined Cap’s title for a long period during the 1970s; for some of us growing up during that period, “Captain America and the Falcon” was as ubiquitous as “Batman and Robin.”) Sam Wilson already has legendary status as comics’ first African American superhero. The Black Panther came earlier, but he is African in origin. Sam Wilson, however, was the first black man from America to be a superhero, so seeing him rise to rank of Captain America is no small thing.

What Marvel has done with All-New Captain America is both super smart and super ballsy. It’s smart because after the immense success at the box office of Captain America: the Winter Soldier in move theaters this year, it’s the perfect time to launch an a new Cap series to gain new readers. So what’s the ballsy part? Launching it with his former sidekick holding the title of Captain America instead of Steve Rogers, whom audiences the world over now associate with Cap. This is a complete departure from what fans — both the casual fans who came to Cap with the movies and long time fans of the comic — would expect on the heels of such a massive movie. I have nothing but praise for Marvel for thinking outside the box on this one.

Despite the change in leads, there are a lot of ways that All-New Captain America is very friendly to fans who might have come into the entire Captain America lore through the Marvel movies, regardless of the change in the man behind the mask; just in this first issue alone, you have baddies Hydra and Batroc the Leaper, both of whom figured very prominently in The Winter Soldier. And of course the Falcon, as played by Anthony Mackie, stole every scene he was in during that movie, and this is now Falcon’s book. I’d feel comfortable giving this issue to any fan who only knew Cap from the first two films without worrying that they couldn’t follow it.


If you haven’t read the previous run of Captain America from writer Rick Remender (who returns as writer for this version) he catches you up pretty quickly with the new status quo. After an adventure in Dimension Z, Steve Rogers has all of his super soldier serum drained from him, making him just another ordinary old man, who probably watches a lot Antiques Road Show and eats at Hometown Buffet. He bequeaths his name and shield to his longtime partner Sam Wilson, and that’s where we find ourselves as the first issue opens. Steve still figures into the title in a big way; although he’s a retired old guy spending his days fishing with his lady, he’s still communicating via comlink with Sam in battle and giving him directions, making for a situation very similar to the “old man Bruce” and Terry McGinnis relationship from the animated Batman Beyond series.

The vast majority of the issue is action, action, and more action, with Cap taking on a Hydra and Batroc, beautifully rendered by artist Stuart Immonen. Immonen has been sort of an unsung hero in comics for several years now. Despite truly amazing runs on titles like All-New X-Men, Ultimate Spider-Man and Fear Itself, he’s never become the fan darling that he should have become. Hopefully that changes with this series, because it’s easily some of his most stunning pencils to date. Not to mention, this issue has some of the best action beats I’ve seen from Immonen ever, He knows how to give Sam a real sense of aerodynamic motion, which is harder to do than you might think; let’s face it, a lot of time people flying in comics really just looks like people posing for glamour shots, just up in the air.

Although the artwork steals the show in this issue, the writing from Remender is pretty on point too, as he keeps the dialogue as fun and brisk as the action is. My favorite exchange is when French bad guy Batroc taunts Sam, and says, “Tell me, what is the super power of the modern Captain America? Super obesity? War mongering? Omega level illiteracy?” (It’s kind of hard to disagree with Batroc here.) There are some pretty great exchanges between Sam and his new partner Nomad, who is Cap villain Arnim Zola’s son who Steve Rogers raised in Dimension Z, now all grown up and not too happy that “dad” picked Sam to be the new Cap and not him. This is sure to make for an interesting dynamic as the series continues.


Even though Sam Wilson’s comic book powers and back story have always been a bit convoluted over the years (he was even a mutant for awhile), writer Rick Remender sidesteps a lot of that in this first issue, giving us just the important character beats from his origin. For example,  Sam’s father who was a preacher in Harlem who was murdered, causing a young Sam Wilson to lose hope, before finding it again fighting alongside Steve Rogers. Remender skips the whole “Red Skull/Cosmic Cube/sees through the eyes of millions of birds” aspects of his origin, which is for the best. The movie showed us all you need for a cool Sam Wilson is a pair of artificial wings and a lot of maneuverability, and the comic gives us just that, even if his old bird pal Redwing is there.

I guess if there’s one bummer about this issue, it’s just that I know it’s all temporary and fleeting. I applaud Marvel for bringing diversity to their highest profile titles, but I know that within the next year or two Thor will be a man again and Captain America will be good old Steve Rogers. But I can’t worry about that now, and should just judge this issue for what it’s doing right right now. And right now it’s not only bringing in tons of needed diversity to the iconic Marvel heroes, but it’s a hell of a lot of fun to read too.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5 burritos

3.5 burritos

John Cleese Recapping THE WALKING DEAD Is Simply Delightful

John Cleese Recapping THE WALKING DEAD Is Simply Delightful

Hyper Realistic Superhero Portraits Are Amazing and Terrifying

Hyper Realistic Superhero Portraits Are Amazing and Terrifying

THE WALKING DEAD Premiere Had a Subtle Heartbreaking Moment You Might Have Missed

THE WALKING DEAD Premiere Had a Subtle Heartbreaking Moment You Might Have Missed



  1. Jim Purcell says:

    aryan poster boy . nice sensationalistic writing .
    don’t push the racist button to write a review .

  2. Aryan poster boy? Steve Rogers was from a poor Irish Catholic family. Hardly an Aryan poster boy. 

    • Calmiera says:

      Captain America was created as a response to Hitler and Nazi Germany. That’s why he IS an Aryan poster boy. His appearance is exactly what Nazis considered ideal – and yet, on the cover of the first issue he is punching Hitler.

  3. x100robots says:

    I love Stuart Immonen, he is one of my favorite artists working in comics today and I thought the writing in this issue was superb (especially after those horrible digital issues Marvel put out featuring the new Cap). 
    The one thing I can’t get behind is how they sidelined Rogers. Steve has always been my favorite Marvel character so to see him taken out of action by a C-list villain (and a brand new-ish one to boot) and turned into an elderly gentleman (nothing wrong with those of us who’ve aged a bit) was pretty ham fisted. It seems obvious that they were unwilling to kill him (again) so they could bring him back in some form down the road, but I would have much rather had him have an ending that was fitting of such a long running and important (at least in my mind) character instead literally sidelining him (also would it kill them to make a style guide for old man Steve? He’s currently the least consistently drawn character in the Marvel U).
    Additionally it’s super sad when you consider that he’s been transformed into an old man but was unable to actually have a life for all those years he aged. He was frozen in ice and missed out on the majority of his youth and the middle of his life due to a guy named Iron Nail for Pete’s sake, not during an epic punch out with the Red Skull while falling into a black hole like you might expect.
    Seeing Falcon, who I’ve been a fan of for a long time, take up the mantle is a thrill and I like that direction a lot. But Marvel doesn’t need to make us like this new Cap by disrespecting the fans and the memory of the previous cap. 

    • Ken says:

      Maybe they can put Steve Rogers in an exoskeleton, like Mark Verheiden did with Eisenhower in The American (always had a soft spot for that series).

  4. lame says:

    “hey, we work in comics, all these comic book movies keep coming out with our characters. I got an idea, lets just change EVERYTHING just to be assholes cuz we can! well make thor a girl, we’ll just kill wolverine, and we’ll just get rid of captain america and replace him. Why not? It will differentiate us from all these movies!!”

    • Brytling says:

      I sort of agree. Has it never donned on anyone that all these comicbook  movies make these characters even “more” popular? I feel changing them will have the opposite effect. People will stop reading because its no longer the character they like so much in the movie.

  5. I am actually of an age to remember those Captain America and the Falcon days, which why I was so excited to see the Falcon in Winter Soldier. This is very cool and I intend to enjoy the ride.

  6. Manuel Jung says:

    “Aryan Poster Boy”? Quite being racist Diaz!

    • ericmci says:

      Yeah- I am assuming you are exaggerating with the racist.  But whoa whoa whoa- Aryan poster boy = Not cool and really off base considering Steve Rogers history.  And I also completely disagree with any of the New Cap being accessible to new readers.  Maybe part of the problem is that people are already calling him “Cap’ that shiz has to be earned.  Sam as The Falcon a lot of respect is due.  AS the new Captain America that takes more than  minutes.  I feel the writing in terms of characterization has taken too many short cuts.I’ve been reading the train wreck known as Axis and I still dont get all of the issues with why the New ‘Cap’ is being such a dick.  Not sure how a new reader would be able to make heads or tails of it.  Remender is just simply off his game, ballsy or not.